Director Larry Charles (also directed Borat) describes the project:
What do you believe, why do you believe it, and why do you need to believe it? Can we be good without God? Is religion a calling or a mental illness? Were Jesus, Moses and Mohammed prophets and visionaries, or crackpot nut cases who today would be put away? Is religion an obsessive-compulsive disorder?
Comedian, acerbic commentator, raconteur, skeptic, seeker Bill Maher and I set off in search of answers to these questions in a raunchy, rude, irreverent, outrageous, and shocking nonfiction film about the greatest fiction ever told.
I have long been disappointed by the exemplars of atheism and agnosticism. Some of the most famous doubters are complete douches. Maher on the other hand is firm in his beliefs and, though he has at times been rather dismissive of people of faith, he's not unable to have a real conversation and he can still see people of faith as humans.
By the way something, Seamus O'Rourke and I had an interesting conversation about documentaries the other day. We agreed that for the most part they give people the impression that they're watching something truthful and on the level, when most of them have obvious biases they're not owning up to.
I think that the approach that Maher is taking here, however, is obviously not a documentary. We need a new genre term for these personality driven non-fiction films. But I like this approach because Maher is so far out in front of it that it can't be mistaken for anything other than something that may or may not be interesting that a comedian is doing.